Showing posts with label Elizabeth Stark. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Elizabeth Stark. Show all posts

Monday, May 14, 2012

Leaving Mundania: Thoughts on Chapters 2 and 3

by Zoe

A continuation of my rambling thoughts on Lizzie Stark's new book Leaving Mundania. Go check it out! You can buy it at a bookstore, order it online, or get an online e-copy.

Chapter Two

1) The Gaming Family
This chapter covers a family of gamers: 2 sons, a father, and an adoptive son (friend of the family). All in all, it's a nice character portrait of how gaming functions in a family. (With that being said, I'm not sure how well it fits into the theme of the overall book-- it feels a little random.) With that being said, I do think this covers an aspect of LARPing that is frequently under-appreciated, and I'm glad Stark calls attention to it. This is, of course, the family dynamic of LARPing. A lot of people who started LARPing 10 or 20 years ago now have children (of a variety of ages), and, in some cases, these kids are getting involved in games. In one instance, the child of a well-respected LARPer is writing and executing plot for a game (with, I'm told, excellent results). In at least two games, I've seen seen adult players bring their mothers or fathers into a game, either as PCs or NPCs. I LARP with my husband, and I know a lot of people LARP with their partners-- for Chris and I, it's an important part of our relationship. There are also well-known LARPer families where siblings, parents, and aunts or uncles all LARP together. I think the family aspect of gaming is an important one, and also something that bears more consideration. For many of us, our LARPing groups are our chosen familes; for some of us, LARPs are extensions of our biological families. Both instances attest to the community component of LARPing.

2) Defining "LARP"
One of the strengths and weaknesses of Stark's book is her wide definition of LARPing: as I alluded to in an earlier post, she includes many, many, many things that she includes under the category "LARP." Here's my problem with this: even for someone "indoctrinated," it gets confusing. By nature, I'm a categorizing individual, it's true; that admitted, it would have been much more useful to me, as a reader, if she had chosen to organize different live-action experiences into smaller subcategories. She does, in fairness, explain the mechanics of different LARPs as she introduces them: however, it is often a little haphazard, and lacks any straightforward organization. As I read, I was often trying to figure out, "Ok, is this a boffer larp? A theater larp? What does the "XYZ" system mean?" LARPing is complicated pursuit, and I would have preferred some clarification. If you're talking about theater, for instance, it's useful to group it into distinct categories. An example: if I say, "I went to a play this weekend, and I really hated that style of theater," it's beneficial for me to talk about what type of theater I specifically hated (e.g., absurdist or musical). While Stark does report the different mechanics of LARPing, including the use of puzzles, dice, stat cards, and boffers, I don't feel she really does justice to how differently these games actually work. Accordingly, in the text, I get confused about the context in which she's writing. A theater LARP and a boffer LARP are two entirely different beasts, with markedly different communities and gameplay elements: it's useful to provide operative definitions of each one.

Chapter 3

1) The Historical Approach
I think this chapter, which covers historical developments in LARPing, is one of Stark's best. Looking at the trajectory and prevalence of roleplaying, historically, is a really fascinating way to approach the activity. I would really like to examine the history of roleplaying more broadly, and look at non-European activities as well. Stark looks, particularly, at 16th century Europe, and her argument is quite strong. I also like the separation Stark implies between "fancy dress" or costuming and actual roleplaying (32). I think it's an important differentiation, especially when you start looking at people's emotional investment in a LARP. I also now have a nifty summer research topic.

2) Myth in LARP
One of the interesting things that Stark narrates is the use of myth in LARP encounters. Stark talks about Queen Elizabeth the First's larp exploits, many of which involve interactions with mythic figures. I think this is an interesting parallel between modern and historical larping: the use of myth is powerful and pervasive.

3) Emotion in LARP
One of the quotes that caught my attention was the following:

"The yearning to experience personal emotion is one of the hallmarks of life today. Many larpers want to experience emotions-- the lost of a friend, the thrill of battle, the pain of betrayal-- that they would never have occasion to feel in every day life." (38)

I don't disagree with this statement, but I think it's a superficial understanding of LARPs. Firstly, yes, I do agree that some LARPers play because they want to experience emotions that they wouldn't otherwise encounter (as Stark describes). However, I think just as many, if not more, LARPers play to interact with emotions they have most certainly experienced multiple times. LARP is, if nothing else, an arena in which one can safely work through intense emotions. These emotions can include love, hatred, disdain, respect, fear, rage and loss. LARP provides us with a closed space that is an experimental tank for fundamental human emotions. I'm going to give a couple examples, as I think this an important aspect of LARPing:

a) I just got back from NPCing an Endgame event; as always, I was really impressed by the emotional investment of all players in the game. Endgame is an Accelerant post-apocalyptic LARP, and, of all the games I've played, I find it to be one of the most emotionally taxing events for PCs and NPCs alike. I'm not going to go into detail, to preserve player anonymity, but players broadcast a wide range of intense emotions that flair up throughout the game. (Endgame has a "Shaken" trait mechanic that can bring out people's inner messes. In other words, the PCs are "triggered.") I think Endgame offers, to players, a stage on which they can enact real life emotions: fear, sadness, love, loss, confusion, obsession, pride etc. I'm pretty sure most players, on some level, have experienced these feelings. However, Endgame provides everyone with the stimulus to explore them more fully.

b) My longest-running PC, of only about 3 years, is Esme of Madrigal. Esme is a bleeding-heart who really wants to help as many people (well, non-humans) as possible. However, she puts herself in dangerous and stigmatizing situations to do so-- talking at length with vampires, joining the Maladicted Web, and questioning "species-cleansing" options of combat. This was an exploration of my own personal inclinations in real life. To wax obnoxiously self-reflective for a minute, I'm an animal studies scholar interested in pursuing the relations of humans and non-humans. On multiple occasions, I've presented my work to an audiences of peers who laughed away the sentience and capabilities of non-humans. It's been an uphill struggle to legitimate the importance of multispecies approaches in academia. Esme has been, accordingly, an opportunity to explore my real-life interests-- the social agency of non-humans-- in a fantasy setting. When considering ethics, in real life, I often ask myself, "What would happen if non-humans, including plants and animals, could talk, and, more troublingly, fight back?" Well, in a fantasy setting, the non-humans can talk and fight back. This dynamic, however fantastical, allows me to explore things that emotionally important to me, in the real world, on a larger and experimental scale.

I really encourage everyone to pick up this book. In many ways, I disagree with much of Stark's research. However, I think it is really pushing me to consider how I think about LARP. This intellectual stimulus is, I think, one of the benefits of having an outside person write seriously on LARPing.

Friday, May 11, 2012

Leaving Mundania Review

So I started reading Lizzie Stark's new book, Leaving Mundania, and, so far, she has some really interesting points. Some of them are really observant, and some of them are problematic. Over the course of the next few days, I'm going to be posting quotes from specific chapters, including my thoughts on them. I'll post a chapter a day, and I encourage everyone to add their feedback (especially if they've read the book, or are in the process of reading the book). Leaving Mundania is available as an ebook for $9.99; you can also pick it up on amazon or at a local bookstore.

Lizzie Stark is actively in conversation with LARPers, and her book is one of the first to really address LARPing, as a hobby and phenomenon, thoughtfully. I think it would be good, for the entire community, to provide her with some constructive and engaged feedback. My thoughts on the first chapter will go up later today.

Thursday, May 3, 2012

LARP and Journalism

by Zoe

Lizzie Stark of elizabethstark.com has made the foray into LARPing; her new book, Leaving Mundania was just released. I haven't had the chance to read it yet, but my copy is ordered, and hopefully shipping soon. I just discovered Stark's blog, and I'm interested. All this being said, my anthropologist alarm is beeping. My concerns are below, but I encourage everyone else to voice their reactions as well. (Also, please forgive the plunge into anthropological method and theory. I work with what I've got.)

Lizzie Stark, and please correct me if I'm wrong, has LARPed for 18 months. In that time period, she has conducted some fantastic journalism, interviewed intelligent people, and participated in really interesting events. However, 18 months seems like a really short turn around for LARP. Having LARPed now for about 3 years (in Accelerant), I still, as an academic and a player, wouldn't feel comfortable writing an article on it. Why? I'm only just now starting to get a grasp on what makes LARP tick. That's taken three years of PCing, NPCing, staffing, blogging, and researching LARP. Stark is maybe just a different academic than I am, but I can't help but wonder if she's gone for breadth rather than depth. (In fairness, she spent 3 years on the book. That's standardish fieldwork time, I spose.)

My second issue... Stark seems to advocate expanding the definition of LARP to a broader range of activities. She puts "larp" in historical perspective, and categorizes a wide array of activities under the umbrella category of "larp." (I'm all for putting LARP in historical perspective, though I don't know that I'd categorize those activities as directly comparable to modern day LARPing. We run into the same problem with archaeology and comparative ethnography-- historical comparisons can trivialize the individuality of the extant community.) I'm undecided on whether or not this is a good idea. LARPers are part of a stigmatized community. While expanding the definition of LARP to a wider range of activities may make LARPing more palatable to a popular audience, it also risks sacrificing the integrity and nuances of individual LARP games. For instance, Accelerant and NERO, while both LARPs, are wildly different from one another in system, character motivation, and experience. How different then is an Accelerant LARP from some of the examples that Stark presents? Does it do justice to the individual games and players to lump them into an umbrella category? Again, I haven't read her book, so I don't know just how large her definition is. This is mostly gleaned from her blog and interviews. But I'm interested. And really curious about Nordic larps.

My third issue... and Chris Wilkins helped me articulate this: LARP is about LARPers. One of my biggest problems with writing about LARP academically is that it is a fully immersive experience that, in many ways, is meta-cultural. It is best represented by the people who LARP themselves (hence this blog). I get that journalism is all about representing others, but I'm a collaborative anthropologist. Not a journalist. I just have this feeling that she is an outsider looking in. I'm reading over her blog now, I feel like she has some really interesting questions and points, but is still kind of just scratching on the surface of LARP.

This is a cursory look at Stark's work, and I'm interested in learning more about her methods. As an anthropologist, I'm immediately concerned that she hasn't spent enough time in game. I also explained my larger concerns about extending the word "LARP" to a broader definition. Once I read the book, which I'm excited to do, I'll have a better feel, but these are my, admittedly, knee-jerk reactions. I do, however, need to wholeheartedly commend Stark on being respectful of LARPing as a whole-- she's definitely doing her part, from what I can do, to challenge many of the preconceptions about LARPing. And for that I really congratulate and thank her. I don't think Stark intends for her book to be comprehensive nor definitive. I have some concerns, but, if nothing else, it's a good starting point for future writers.

I hope to get the LARPcast fellows and a few other people involved in a roundtable discussion of the book. If you're interested, please let me know.